The AYEI Alumni Association consists of past students on the Advisory Board who have graduated from high school. Though they have graduated, they are still part of the organization and serve as contacts for current grade school students interested in exploring higher education at institutions they have attended. The Association hopes to assist seniors going through the application process by answering questions and providing resources. Notable universities and colleges below include those that are part of our alumni circle:

​

St. Norbert, MIT, Cleveland Institute of Music, Lawrence, Northwestern, UW Madison, Yale, West Point, Columbia, University of Washington in St. Louis, Johns Hopkins, Princeton, Case Western Reserve, George Washington University, Williams College, Stanford, and UC Berkeley